See All Mattresses

Casper vs Plushbeds In Depth Comparison

From our experts

• Construction
• Durability
• Cooling
• Warrenty
• Back pain
• Sleep Type
• Dimension
• Conclusion

Construction

Casper Mattresses8.9

Original Hybrid Mattress

The construction of this mattress is in four distinct layers, each serving a purpose.

Details

Polyurethane Top Layer

On the first layer is a polyurethane foam which is breathable and allows for cooling.

Memory Foam Layer

Beneath the polyurethane foam lies a memory foam which is unique in spine alignment while serving as a supporting layer.

Polyurethane Supporting Layer

Another polyurethane foam is second to the last layer. This one screams of more quality and firmness than the one atop the layers. This is due to its position in the supporting layers.

Hybrid Base Layer

Underneath the three layers of this mattress is a hybrid polyurethane foam with innersprings for reinforced support.

Wave Hybrid Mattress

With special attention given to coolness and comfort, this mattress comes in 5 unique layers.

Details

Polyurethane Top Layer

At the top of the descending layers of this mattress, there is a polyurethane foam which is breathable with a special Cooling technology – AirScape. Undeniably, coolness is a given here.

Original Latex Layer

Just beneath the polyurethane gracing the top as cover is another layer of foam sourced from natural latex for added softness and comfort.

Memory Foam Layer

Sitting at the layer is a memory foam significant for contouring and back support.

Polyurethane Supporting Layer with Gel Pods

Just before the last layer is another not too rigid polyurethane foam serving as supporting layer. It’s not alone. Paired alongside gel pods, it’s renewed softness, more comfort and better spine alignment for the sleeper.

Original Polyurethane Hybrid Foundation

At the foot of it all, lies a hybrid foam made of original Polyurethane foam and innersprings for even more support. The springs create a bouncy feel and aids more air flow.

Nova Hybrid Mattress.

This mattress features 7 layers of support all in the foundation layer and all incorporated into four basic layers which include:

Polyurethane Top Layer

As seen in the other brands, a breathable Polyurethane foam sits at the top most layer providing non-stop air flow and cooling effect.

Zoned Polyurethane Foam

At the second layer is a zoned polyurethane foam that is equally breathable and soft.

Contoured Memory Foam

At the third layer of this mattress construction is a contoured Memory foam to contour the body perfectly and serve the back sleeper well.

Hybrid Foundation

At the base layer is a hybrid combination of Polyurethane foam and individually wrapped coils for extra lift and maximum air flow.

Plushbeds Mattresses9.4

Botanical Bliss

The Botanical Bliss comes in two levels of firmness: medium firm and medium. It’s also available in 9 inches, 10 inches and 12 inches. This mattress is made from 100% organic latex, with the inclusion of wool and cotton to the mix. The construction is in four layers for the 12 inches and 3 layers for both 9 and 10 inches.

Construction Details

Organic Cotton Cover

In the three varied inches of same mattress, an inch of organic cotton cover overlays the top layer. This cover is breathable, allowing for airflow to keep the sleeper cool all night.

9 inches Model

All three layers are made of organic 100% arpico latex and blended with up to 10 lbs of natural wool.

The first layer is 2 inches

The second and third are both 3 inches.

10 inches Model

Same 100% organic arpico latex makes the entire 3 layers. All 3 layers are 3 inches high and all blended with 10 lbs of natural wool.

12 inches Model

The 12 inches rose that high due to the addition of an extra layer making it four in total. The extra layer is 2 inches and sits at the top while the remaining 3 layers below it are all 3 inches high. Same natural latex and wool combination.

Luxury Bliss Latex

The Luxury Bliss is a hybrid mattress and is 12 inches high. Comes in two firmness: medium and medium-firm. Every layer is made from organic Dunlop Latex. It’s construction is in 2 layers.

Construction Details

Organic Cotton Cover and Wool

The entire mattress is wrapped in organic cotton cover which is sheer breathable and assures of a cool sleep. This cover is blended with organic Joma wool. The wool serves as the comfort layer alongside the cover. The wool is also a fire barrier.

Dunlop Latex

The first layer beneath the cover and comfort layer is occupied by 3 inches of Natural Dunlop Latex offering all the prime benefits of nature.

Pocketed Coils Support Core

Serving as the base is 8 inches of 15-16 pocketed coils for the resilient support, durability and over-all performance this mattress offers.

Natural Bliss Mattress

The Natural Bliss Mattress comes in 3 levels of thickness: 6 inches, 8 inches and 10 inches. It has four level of firmness: Soft, medium-firm, medium and firm. Each of the variant comes with different number of layers and is either made of Organic Dunlop Latex or Talalay Latex.

Construction Details

For the 6 inches Model ( one Layer)

Organic Cotton Cover

All three variants use same organic cotton cover for breathability and comfort.

Dunlop Latex Layer

This mattress is only one layer and that’s the 6 inches of Organic Dunlop Latex. It has no support core and no wool addition.

8 inches Model (2 layers)

Cover – remains the same

Comfort Layer

The comfort layer here is 2 inches of Talalay Latex. Talalay is more responsive and feels bouncy.

Support Core Layer

The second layer here which is also the support core is 6 inches of Organic Dunlop Latex for durability and structural stability.

10 inches Model ( 4 Layers )

Cover – remains the same

Comfort Layer

Two layers are in charge of comfort here. Both layers are 2 inches in height and are made of Talalay Latex.

Support Core

The support core is also in two layers, each is 3 inches high and are made of Organic Dunlop Latex.

Durability

Casper Mattresses8.7

All three mattresses from Casper are built with durable foams in their bases and in every other layer. This makes the question of durability negligible and to further to substantiate this, a warranty is in place.

Plushbeds Mattresses9.4

All plushbeds mattresses are made to last. With materials derived from natural sources, they are designed for years of comfort and 25 years of assurance is already stamped.

Cooling and Comfort

Casper Mattresses8.7

Original Hybrid Mattress

To ensure maximum coolness is attained, the cover of this mattress come with a layer of Airscape foam which was intentionally made porous so it can be breathable. Breathability leads to increased air flow and coolness. The memory foam in the mix is soft and comforting as it contours your body frame carefully.

Wave Hybrid Mattress

A mixture of foam and coils is the perfect definition of comfort and coolness. But there’s more.

Here there are 3 layers of perforated foam which are sheer breathable. To further assure coolness is non-negotiable, there’s a cooling gel in the mix. The coils beneath gives you the added lift and the premium polyurethane foam ensures you feel cozy in it’s softness.

Nova Hybrid Mattress

There are two layers of this mattress that assures any sleeper of sheer comfort and coolness. The first layer is the Airscape layer that is soft and breathable. The other layer is split into 3 firmness level for back support.

With the Airscape technology in place, it’s non-stop cooling effect for any sleeper. It allows for maximum traffic of air in and out of the mattress due to its perforated surface. Thus cooling is achieved.

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Since natural latex is involved in all the mattresses, coolness is assured. Organic latex sleeps cooler than memory foam and to further enhance this coolness, it features an open cell construction.

The ultra-mild organic cotton cover present in the mattresses gives room for uninterrupted air flow to keep things cool with the sleeper at the top and it’s softness offers cradle comfort.

In some of the variants where Talalay was used instead of Dunlop Latex, it’s even great news since Talalay is more responsive, soft and bouncy.

Back Pain Support

Casper Mattresses8.7

Original Hybrid Mattress

With three zones dedicated for support, you can be rest assured that your spine and every other back related pains are considered in the construction of this mattress.

There is a rigid foam on the base layer with innersprings that helps to balance your spine properly. The memory foam also works for spine alignment while the sturdy original Polyurethane foam relieves pressure off your back.

Wave Hybrid Mattress

There are supportive gel pods immersed into the supporting layer of this mattress. They are intentionally positioned in the waist and lower back region to keep your spine in proper alignment while preventing them from sinking too low.

Nova Hybrid Mattress

The Nova Hybrid has a zoned memory foam that contours the back perfectly while emphasizing on the back and shoulders. This prevent the sleeper from sinking too deep while his/her weight is evenly distributed to reduce pressure on the back region. This back alignment feature is also supported by it’s hybrid construction of individually wrapped coils.

Plushbeds Mattresses9.5

The Botanical Bliss Mattress that makes use of 100% latex is being prescribed by orthopedics as a viable option for back pain therapy. The latex in this mattress contours the pressure points in your body and relief pressure ultimately off the back.

This same 100% natural Latex is also found in the Luxury Bliss and  Natural Bliss Mattresses, implying that they all provide the needed cradle support for back pressure relief as well as other pressure points in the body of a sleeper.

Trial and Warrenty

Casper Mattresses8.8

All mattresses from Casper have a limited 100 nights usage for trial. Afterwards you can return your mattress and get your money back if you feel unsatisfied by the quality or witness any defects.

The mattresses also come with a limited 10 year warranty.

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Plushbeds offer a 100-night sleep trial on all mattresses. However, there’s a break-in period which lasts for 30-nights. Returning your mattress in the course of the first 30-nights attracts a $99 deduction from your refund. After the 100 nights, you can return the mattress if you don’t like it and get a refund.

For warranty, Plushbeds gives you a limited 25-year warranty. For the first 10 years, Plushbeds is going to replace your mattress or bear the cost of fixing it. Outside the first 10 years, repairs will be done at prorated costs.

Terms and conditions always apply.

Sleeping Type

Casper Mattresses8.8

Original Hybrid Mattress

This original hybrid mattress caters for the needs of every sleeper.

For side sleepers, the zoned support layer cuddles the shoulder and keeps the rest of the body especially the spine in proper alignment.

The back and stomach sleepers are not left out. This hybrid mattress sits on the medium firm position of the firmness scale and covers every kind of sleeper.

Wave Hybrid Mattress

At 6.5 on the firmness scale, the wave hybrid might not be the ideal one-firmness-fits-all sleepers kind of mattress.

Back Sleepers

For back sleepers, the coils beneath provide support and adequate firmness at the back coupled with a memory foam layer that contours perfectly. An additional latex layer limits sinkage to crown it all for back sleepers.

Side Sleepers

For side sleepers, this is also a great mattress so long as they are not too heavy.

Stomach Sleepers

For the stomach sleepers, this might not be the ideal mattress since it’s top layers are super soft and might not provide the needed firmness for their hips.

Nova Hybrid Mattress

The Nova hybrid mattress is on the medium soft range on the firmness scale.

For side and back sleepers, this mattress is ideal but for stomach sleepers, they might need to reconsider because this mattress might not grant them the extra support they need for their hips.

 

Plushbeds Mattresses9.2

Botanical Bliss

Since the Botanical Bliss comes in medium and medium-firm levels, it means that every sleeper can enjoy this mattress and more importantly, side and stomach sleepers are to going enjoy it better.

Luxury Bliss

Same firmness levels are present in the luxury mattress: medium and medium firm. Choose medium if you are chiefly a side sleeper and medium-firm if you are not loyal to any sleeping position all night.

Natural Bliss

The Natural Bliss packs almost all levels of firmness. Choose

Soft: If you are a side sleeper

Medium: if you are a side sleeper and back sleeper as well.

Medium-firm: if you change positions all night.

Extra-firm: if you are a back sleeper and a stomach sleeper.

Dimensions

Conclusion

Plushbeds and Casper are both in the same league when it comes to their offerings. They offer three different mattresess each and that’s good for diversity since sleepers come with varying needs and choices.

Both mattresses also come with the same level of firmness. Each mattress has a unique firmness level attached to it and not necessarily a one-size-fits-all approach to the firmness feel. This gives sleepers special attention to the needs of their preferred sleeping positions.

However, PlushBeds leads when it comes to offering better comfort in a mattress. PlushBeds is a much more durable mattress with much better back support so overall PlushBeds is a much better option.